top of page

Before “For Him” and “For Her”: Fragrance Beyond Gender

Nov 4
5 min read

When I first released Roma Noir and Roma Bianca, I thought I knew who each fragrance was for. Noir’s deep, resinous woods felt masculine to me. Bianca’s light, delicate, soft florals felt feminine. I had made the familiar distinction almost without questioning it: this one for men, that one for women.

Then people began wearing them, and the neat division I had imagined started to disappear. That experience sent me back to a much older question: when did we decide that a smell should belong to a particular gender?

Fragrance came long before the men’s and women’s counters

There is no single, securely documented moment when someone invented fragrance and declared its intended wearer. Perfumery developed across ancient cultures. The University of Missouri’s Museum of Art and Archaeology traces it back at least 5,000 years, with roots in Mesopotamia, Egypt and the Indus Valley, followed by further development in the Bronze Age Mediterranean. [1]

Its purposes were much broader than personal attraction. In Greek and Roman societies, scent belonged to religious offerings, funerary practices and displays of wealth and rank. Perfumed oils also accompanied athletic life. The museum’s account describes a world in which occasion, materials and social position helped determine how fragrance was used. [1]

Egypt offers another useful example. The Global Egyptian Museum documents cosmetics, including oils, ointments and perfume, and explains that cosmetic practices were shared by men and women. Oxford’s Pitt Rivers Museum describes fragrant plant materials steeped in oil or fat for application to the skin, alongside aromatic substances used in embalming and funeral rituals. These were not simply ancient versions of today’s department-store categories. [2][3]

It would go too far to say that every fragrance in every ancient society was completely free of gender associations. Customs varied, and modern terms such as “gender-neutral” do not map neatly onto ancient lives. The stronger historical point is that fragrance was never exclusively a women’s practice or a men’s practice. Today’s rigid “for him” and “for her” retail division is not an original, universal rule of perfumery.

How marketing made the categories feel natural

A fragrance is difficult to sell through an advertisement because the audience cannot smell it. A campaign therefore sells an image around the scent: a person, a mood, an aspiration, a way of being seen. Names, bottles, colors, photography and placement on a store shelf can tell shoppers who a fragrance is supposedly for before they ever try it.

The Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History describes how powerful brand identities and advertising helped fragrance companies dominate the American market. It also documents the development of a distinct market for men’s fragrance, including the growing popularity of brands such as Old Spice and Aqua-Velva in the early 1950s as men’s grooming habits changed after World War II. This is a history of commerce and social expectations developing together. [4]

Once those expectations become familiar, they can feel like properties of the ingredients themselves. Woods and leather suggest masculinity; flowers and softness suggest femininity. But those associations are interpretations. A rose note does not carry an instruction about who should wear it, and a resinous wood accord does not exclude a woman.

Marketing did not create every difference in taste, and people are free to enjoy fragrances that express a masculine or feminine identity. The problem comes when a useful description becomes a restriction. A label can help someone navigate a crowded shelf, but it can also persuade them to ignore something they might love.

What Roma Noir and Roma Bianca taught me

My own launch made that restriction impossible to ignore. As I remember it, 73,000 people tried to buy Roma Noir and Roma Bianca on the day they came out, and 1,000 received their orders. What stayed with me was what happened once those fragrances reached the people who would wear them.

As the fragrances reached people, I began to notice that many women were more drawn to Noir than Bianca. Men were wearing both equally. The resinous woods that I had mentally assigned to men appealed to women. The soft florals that I had imagined for women appealed to men.

This was my experience with my customers, rather than a formal study of fragrance preferences. It was still enough to change my approach. I had attached gender to the compositions; the people wearing them were choosing through their own response to the scent.

I decided that the rest of my collection, and every fragrance I create from now on, would be unisex or carry no gender designation. I want someone to encounter the fragrance without first having to decide whether the bottle gives them permission to wear it.

A shared bottle is not a new idea

The move beyond gender labels has an important modern history of its own. CK One, launched in 1994, made the idea of a fragrance for everyone highly visible through its identity and advertising. Calvin Klein’s account of the launch describes a campaign rooted in youth culture and an inclusive cast. Its 2024 CK One Essence release continued that emphasis on individuality and togetherness. [5]

That makes CK One a useful milestone in modern marketing, rather than a sensible starting date for shared fragrance itself. People had used and shared scent long before the 1990s. What changed was how prominently a major brand could place that idea at the center of its message.

Why gender is disappearing from some fragrance labels

Today, some fragrance houses lead with the composition, a memory or a mood rather than an exclusively male or female customer. Byredo, for example, explicitly describes Gypsy Water as “Genderless” on its product page, alongside its woody character and intensity. Jo Malone London’s Australian site presents its cologne collection under the description “Unisex Perfume.” These are concrete examples of a less gender-restrictive approach, not proof that the entire industry has abandoned gender categories. [6][7]

There is also a difference between a bottle with no gender designation and a product sold without gendered marketing. A plain bottle may still appear in a retailer’s men’s or women’s department. Conversely, a fragrance described as unisex can still use imagery or language that suggests a particular audience. The full presentation matters.

Calling this a return makes sense in one respect: it reconnects us with the long history of fragrance as a shared human practice. It should not imply that the past was a single, perfectly inclusive era. The opportunity now is to give people more room to choose for themselves.

Let the fragrance make its case

For anyone exploring beyond a familiar label, start with the qualities you actually enjoy: dry or sweet, airy or dense, floral or woody, bright or smoky. Try the fragrance without treating its category as a verdict. Give it time on your skin, and notice whether you enjoy both its opening and the scent that remains.

You can love a fragrance that feels masculine, feminine, both or neither. You can wear different styles on different days. None of those choices needs to be defended by the words on a bottle.

For me, Roma Noir and Roma Bianca made the lesson personal. The people wearing them saw possibilities that my original labels had narrowed. Going forward, I want the collection to leave those possibilities open. The scent can tell its story. The person wearing it gets to decide what that story means to them.

Sources and further reading

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Roma Scent Trials

Monthly 5 mL Roma minis, a vote on what we release next, Roma Media app beta access and 100 Roma coins to start (no monthly recharge). Monthly: $39.95. Annual juror: $299.

 
 

Comments


bottom of page